flow

Decision 0069 · Accepted

Direction changes gate at adoption,
not discussion

0038 made explore stop at any goal that contradicts an Accepted decision, spec, or PRODUCT.md fact.

Status
Accepted
Built from:
da88c48

Status: Accepted (2026-11-08). Spec: 069. Amends 0038 (item 1: when the gate applies) and 0044 (item 6: a request that already authorizes writing an agreed brief needs no second confirmation).

Context

0038 made explore stop at any goal that contradicts an Accepted decision, spec, or PRODUCT.md fact. That also stops a peer from examining "what if we merged duplicates automatically?" or running a bounded experiment, though nothing is being adopted. The cost of a wrong adoption sits at acceptance and implementation, where the commitment text changes.

Decision

  1. Surface in discussion, gate at adoption. During explore, name the existing commitment (file and statement) when it matters and let the hypothetical or bounded experiment proceed. A prototype or implementation discrepancy never creates a product promise.
  2. A draft spec that changes a commitment states the current statement, the proposed replacement, and the observable consequence, marked as a proposal. It is resolved before the spec is accepted or built, unless the user already chose the new direction with that consequence understood; that authorization is used once.
  3. At adoption the affected owner document changes through the existing acceptance step. A numbered record is written only where 0063 applies; changing an Accepted decision still gets one (0038 item 2).
  4. Items 2 and 3 of 0038 are unchanged.

Alternatives

  • Keep the gate in explore. Rejected: it blocks cheap, reversible learning and makes the peer defend the status quo.
  • Gate nowhere until build. Rejected: acceptance is where the old text is superseded and back-pointers are written.

Consequences

An agent may discuss and prototype against a commitment without a yes; adopting or shipping the change still needs one. A killed experiment leaves no record.

Jump to, or try a question